HomeBiologyQ
BiologyPhotosynthesis
Find the INCORRECT statement(s) about photosynthesis: A. Water splitting complex is associated with PS I. B. C₄ plants use the C₃ pathway of CO₂ fixation as main biosynthetic pathway. C. In C₄ plants, photorespiration does not occur. D. C₃ plants exhibit Kranz anatomy. E. ATP synthesis in chloroplast occurs through chemiosmosis.
Options
1
B only
2
A and D only
3
B and C only
4
B and E only
Correct Answer
Option 2 : A and D only (incorrect statements)
Solution
1

A ❌ INCORRECT: Water splitting complex → associated with PS II (P680), NOT PS I. PSII splits water: 2H₂O → O₂ + 4H⁺ + 4e⁻.

B ✅ CORRECT: C₄ plants use Calvin (C₃) cycle in bundle sheath cells as main biosynthetic pathway — true.

2

C ✅ CORRECT: C₄ plants do NOT show photorespiration — CO₂ concentration around RuBisCO suppresses oxygenase activity.

D ❌ INCORRECT: Kranz anatomy → characteristic of C₄ plants (maize, sugarcane), NOT C₃ plants.

E ✅ CORRECT: ATP synthesis in chloroplast IS through chemiosmosis (H⁺ gradient → CF₁CF₀ ATP synthase).

Incorrect = A and D
A: Water splitting = PSII not PSI
D: Kranz anatomy = C₄ not C₃
Theory: Photosynthesis
1. Photosystems PSI and PSII — Organisation and Function

Photosystems are protein-pigment complexes embedded in the thylakoid membrane that capture light energy and convert it to chemical energy. Two photosystems work in series: Photosystem II (PSII, P680): absorbs light at 680 nm wavelength. Contains the water-splitting (oxygen-evolving) complex — the site where water is oxidised to produce O₂. This is Statement A in the question — water-splitting complex is associated with PSII, NOT PSI. Associated with the core proteins D1 and D2. Contains Mn₄Ca cluster (4 manganese + 1 calcium) that performs the water-oxidation chemistry. Photosystem I (PSI, P700): absorbs light at 700 nm wavelength. Reduces NADP⁺ to NADPH (via ferredoxin and NADP-reductase/FNR). NOT associated with water splitting. The Z-scheme shows electron flow: PSII → PQ → Cytb6f → PC → PSI → Fd → NADP⁺. Electrons flow from water (PSII) to NADPH (PSI).

2. Statement Analysis — Incorrect Statements in Photosynthesis

Statement A: "Water splitting complex is associated with PS I." — INCORRECT. Water splitting occurs at PSII (P680), NOT PSI. The oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) containing Mn₄Ca is on the lumenal side of PSII. Water is split: 2H₂O → O₂ + 4H⁺ + 4e⁻. The electrons replenish the oxidised P680. Statement D: "C₃ plants exhibit 'Kranz' anatomy." — INCORRECT. Kranz anatomy (bundle sheath cells forming a wreath around vascular bundles) is characteristic of C₄ plants (maize, sugarcane, sorghum), NOT C₃ plants. C₃ plants have typical dicot/monocot leaf anatomy without the specialised bundle sheath. Statements B, C, E are all CORRECT. Statement B: C₄ plants use C₃ pathway (Calvin cycle) as the MAIN biosynthetic pathway — true (C₃ is used in bundle sheath; C₄ is just a CO₂-concentrating mechanism). Statement C: C₄ plants do not show photorespiration — true (CO₂ concentration mechanism suppresses oxygenase activity). Statement E: ATP synthesis via chemiosmosis — true (H⁺ gradient → CF₁CF₀ ATP synthase).

3. Water Splitting — Oxygen-Evolving Complex

The water-splitting (oxygen-evolving) complex (OEC) is located on the lumenal side of PSII, the side facing the interior of the thylakoid. The OEC contains a cluster of 4 manganese ions (Mn₄) and 1 calcium ion (Ca²⁺) — often written Mn₄Ca. The mechanism (Kok cycle / S-state cycle): The OEC cycles through 5 oxidation states S₀ through S₄. Each photon absorbed by PSII oxidises P680 → P680⁺. P680⁺ oxidises the OEC (via Tyr-Z, a tyrosine residue). After 4 oxidations (S₄ state): the OEC has stored 4 oxidising equivalents → splits 2 H₂O → O₂ + 4H⁺ + 4e⁻. Overall: 2H₂O → O₂ + 4H⁺(lumen) + 4e⁻ (to P680⁺). The 4H⁺ released into the lumen contribute to the proton gradient that drives ATP synthesis. O₂ is the byproduct released to the atmosphere. This is why photosynthesis produces O₂ — it comes from WATER, not CO₂.

4. C₄ Plants and Kranz Anatomy

Kranz anatomy (German: Kranz = wreath or garland) is the distinctive leaf anatomy of C₄ plants. Features: (1) Bundle sheath cells form a complete, tightly packed ring (wreath) around each vascular bundle. Bundle sheath cells are large, contain many chloroplasts (with stacked grana or, in some C₄ plants, agranal/reduced-grana chloroplasts), and are enriched in RuBisCO. (2) Mesophyll cells surround the bundle sheath cells and contain chloroplasts with both PSII and PSI (and PEP carboxylase). (3) The two cell types are specialised for the two steps of C₄ photosynthesis. C₃ plants (wheat, rice, spinach, most dicots): do NOT have Kranz anatomy. They have typical leaf anatomy — spongy mesophyll and palisade mesophyll. Bundle sheath cells are present but NOT specially enlarged or enriched in chloroplasts. C₃ plants include wheat, rice, potato, soybean, most trees — responsible for ~85% of Earth's plant biomass.

5. Photorespiration in C₃ vs C₄ Plants

Photorespiration: RuBisCO acts as an oxygenase (instead of carboxylase) when O₂/CO₂ ratio is high. RuBP + O₂ → 3-PGA + 2-phosphoglycolate. 2-phosphoglycolate must be recycled (costly process in peroxisome + mitochondria, releasing CO₂ and consuming ATP/NADPH). Net result: waste of fixed carbon (~25% lost in C₃ plants). Increases with temperature (oxygenase activity increases faster than carboxylase with rising temperature). C₃ plants: significant photorespiration, especially at high temperatures → reduced efficiency in hot environments. C₄ plants: the CO₂ concentration mechanism (CO₂ concentrated in bundle sheath via C₄ pathway) keeps CO₂/O₂ ratio high around RuBisCO → oxygenase activity suppressed → essentially NO photorespiration. This makes C₄ plants more productive in hot, high-light environments. CAM plants: by fixing CO₂ at night (when temperatures are cool), they also avoid high photorespiration.

6. Chemiosmosis in Chloroplasts

ATP synthesis in chloroplasts follows the same chemiosmotic principle as in mitochondria, but in the opposite direction. In thylakoids: H⁺ accumulates in the thylakoid lumen (inside) during: (1) Water splitting at PSII (releases H⁺ into lumen). (2) Plastoquinone (PQ) transfers electrons and H⁺ from stroma to lumen (via the Cytb6f complex). This creates a proton gradient: high [H⁺] inside lumen, low [H⁺] in stroma. H⁺ flows from lumen to stroma through CF₁CF₀ ATP synthase (coupling factor). This drives phosphorylation of ADP → ATP. In mitochondria: H⁺ pumped from matrix to intermembrane space → flows back through ATP synthase (Complex V). The direction is reversed but the chemiosmotic principle is the same (Peter Mitchell, Nobel Prize 1978). The CF₁CF₀ ATP synthase is the chloroplast's energy-converting enzyme.

7. The Z-Scheme of Photosynthesis

The Z-scheme describes the non-cyclic electron flow in light reactions. It is called Z-scheme because the diagram of oxidation-reduction potentials forms a Z-shape. Sequence: H₂O (donor) → OEC/PSII (P680) → Pheophytin (Pheo) → Plastoquinone (PQ) → Cytochrome b6f complex → Plastocyanin (PC) → PSI (P700) → Ferredoxin (Fd) → NADP⁺ reductase (FNR) → NADPH (acceptor). Energy input: 2 photons (one for PSII, one for PSI) per electron. Products per 2 electrons: 1 NADPH, ~1 ATP (from proton gradient via PQ and water splitting). To produce 1 glucose: 18 ATP + 12 NADPH needed → 48 photons required (24 for PSII + 24 for PSI). Cyclic electron flow: PSI only. Fd → Cytb6f → PC → PSI. Only ATP produced (no NADPH, no O₂). Used to adjust ATP/NADPH ratio.

8. Factors Affecting Photosynthesis — Blackman's Law

Blackman's Law of Limiting Factors (1905): when a process is conditioned by multiple factors, the rate is limited by the factor in the least amount (the limiting factor). For photosynthesis, multiple factors can be limiting: Light intensity: below saturation point, photosynthesis is light-limited. Above saturation: CO₂ or temperature becomes limiting. CO₂ concentration: at high light, CO₂ often limits. Elevating CO₂ from 0.04% to 0.1% doubles photosynthesis in C₃ plants. Temperature: affects enzyme-catalysed reactions (Calvin cycle). Optimum ~25-30°C for most plants. Above optimum: enzymes denature. Water: water stress → stomata close → less CO₂ entry → photosynthesis declines. Light quality: red (680 nm) and blue (450 nm) most effective for photosynthesis. Green least absorbed (reflected → leaves appear green). Emerson enhancement effect: using red + far-red together gives more than sum of each alone → proved two photosystems exist.

Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why is water splitting at PSII and not PSI?
PSII (P680) has a higher reduction potential (more oxidising power) than PSI (P700). To oxidise water (E° = +0.82 V), the photosystem must have a redox potential more positive than +0.82 V. P680⁺ (oxidised PSII) has E° ≈ +1.2 V → can oxidise water. P700⁺ (oxidised PSI) has E° ≈ +0.5 V → cannot oxidise water. This is why only PSII can split water. The oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) with Mn₄Ca cluster is physically located on the lumenal side of PSII. Water molecules are coordinated to the Mn cluster and oxidised through the S-state cycle. O₂ released, H⁺ released into lumen, 4e⁻ replenish P680⁺.
2. What exactly is Kranz anatomy?
Kranz (German = wreath/garland) anatomy is the characteristic leaf organisation of C₄ plants. Bundle sheath cells: large, tightly packed cells forming a complete ring around each vascular bundle. Rich in chloroplasts (containing large amounts of RuBisCO). Thick walls (often containing suberin — reduces CO₂ leakage). In NADP-ME type (e.g., maize): bundle sheath chloroplasts are agranal (thylakoids unstacked). In PCK type: bundle sheath chloroplasts have normal grana. Mesophyll cells: loosely arranged, radiate outward from bundle sheath. Contain chloroplasts with PEP carboxylase. Closely connected to bundle sheath by plasmodesmata. The 'two-cell' system of C₄: mesophyll (CO₂ fixation by PEP-C) + bundle sheath (CO₂ release + Calvin cycle by RuBisCO). C₃ plants have undifferentiated mesophyll without specialised bundle sheath.
3. Why don't C₄ plants show photorespiration?
C₄ plants use a CO₂ pump: Step 1 (mesophyll): PEP + CO₂ →(PEP carboxylase, PEPC) OAA → malate (or aspartate). PEPC has very high affinity for CO₂ and DOES NOT react with O₂ (unlike RuBisCO). Step 2 (bundle sheath): malate decarboxylation → CO₂ released in high concentration around RuBisCO. High CO₂/O₂ ratio → RuBisCO acts as carboxylase (not oxygenase) → no 2-phosphoglycolate formed → no photorespiration. Result: C₄ plants save ~25% of fixed carbon that C₃ plants would lose to photorespiration. This gives C₄ plants (maize, sugarcane, sorghum) higher productivity in hot, sunny, arid conditions.
4. What is the main difference between C₃ and C₄ plants?
C₃ plants: First stable product of CO₂ fixation = 3-PGA (3-carbon). One cell type for photosynthesis. RuBisCO fixes CO₂ directly in mesophyll. Significant photorespiration (especially at high T). ~85% of plant species. Examples: wheat, rice, potato, spinach, most trees. Optimum temperature: 15-25°C. C₄ plants: First stable product = OAA (4-carbon) in mesophyll. Two cell types (mesophyll + bundle sheath). CO₂ concentrated around RuBisCO in bundle sheath. No photorespiration. ~3% of plant species. Examples: maize, sugarcane, sorghum, millet, amaranth. Optimum temperature: 30-45°C. C₄ productivity higher in tropical/subtropical environments. C₄ photosynthesis evolved independently ~60+ times in different lineages.
5. What is the role of plastoquinone in photosynthesis?
Plastoquinone (PQ) is a fat-soluble electron carrier that transfers electrons from PSII to the Cyt b6f complex, carrying H⁺ from the stroma to the lumen. Mechanism: Reduced PQH₂ (accepts 2e⁻ and 2H⁺ from stroma) → diffuses to Cyt b6f complex → transfers 2e⁻ (to cytochrome chain) + 2H⁺ (released into lumen) → PQ is regenerated. This Q-cycle pumps additional H⁺ into lumen. PQ is the functional equivalent of ubiquinone (Coenzyme Q) in mitochondrial electron transport. PQ is mobile in the thylakoid membrane → shuttles between PSII and Cyt b6f. The H⁺ pumped into lumen by PQ contributes to the proton gradient for ATP synthesis.
6. How does ATP synthase work in chloroplasts?
The CF₁CF₀ ATP synthase (coupling factor) in chloroplasts works by the same rotary mechanism as mitochondrial ATP synthase (F₁F₀). CF₀ (in thylakoid membrane): proton channel. CF₁ (projecting into stroma): catalytic domain with 3 α/β pairs. When H⁺ flows from lumen → stroma through CF₀: this causes CF₀ c-ring to rotate → drives conformational changes in CF₁ → ADP + Pᵢ → ATP (Boyer's binding change mechanism). The ratio of H⁺ required per ATP varies (~3-4 H⁺/ATP). Inhibitors: venturicidin, DCCD block CF₀. Antimycin A inhibits electron flow (not directly ATP synthase). Uncouplers (dinitrophenol, FCCP): destroy the H⁺ gradient without making ATP → electron flow continues but no ATP.
7. What is cyclic vs non-cyclic photophosphorylation?
Non-cyclic (Z-scheme): involves BOTH PSII and PSI. Products: O₂ + NADPH + ATP. Electrons: H₂O → PSII → PQ → Cyt b6f → PC → PSI → Fd → NADPH. Linear electron flow. Normal (main) pathway. Cyclic: involves ONLY PSI. Products: ATP only (no O₂, no NADPH). Electrons: PSI → Fd → Cyt b6f → PC → PSI (cycle). No PSII, no water splitting. When ATP/NADPH ratio needs adjustment (Calvin cycle needs more ATP per NADPH than non-cyclic provides), cyclic photophosphorylation produces extra ATP. Also: pseudocyclic photophosphorylation (Mehler reaction): PSI reduces O₂ instead of NADP⁺ → H₂O₂ formed → catalase/peroxidase removes it → net: H₂O consumed, ATP produced (no NADPH, no net O₂).
8. What are the products absorbed vs released in overall photosynthesis?
Net equation: 6CO₂ + 12H₂O + light → C₆H₁₂O₆ + 6O₂ + 6H₂O. Note: 12 H₂O on left (in detailed equation) → 6 H₂O on right — net consumption of 6 H₂O. The O₂ released comes from WATER (not CO₂). This was proven by: van Niel (1930s): in purple sulphur bacteria, H₂S + CO₂ → sugar + S (analogous to H₂O + CO₂ → sugar + O₂), demonstrating O₂ must come from H₂O. Samuel Ruben (1941): using ¹⁸O-labelled water (H₂¹⁸O) and normal CO₂ → produced ¹⁸O₂ confirming O₂ from water. CO₂ provides the carbon atoms for glucose. Water provides electrons and H⁺ for reduction reactions, and the O atoms of water become O₂.
Previous Questions
Q.
Main function of bulliform cells in grasses
Plant Anatomy · Answer: Minimise water loss during water stress
Q.
Correct statements about amino acids
Biomolecules · Answer: A and C only
Q.
Alpha-helix is found in which level of protein structure
Biomolecules · Answer: Secondary structure
Q.
Transcription unit — all statements A B C D E correct
Molecular Biology · Answer: All five correct
Q.
NOT characteristic of elongation phase in plant growth
Plant Growth · Answer: Large conspicuous nuclei