HomeBiologyQ
BiologyGenetics
In which animal do haploid cells divide mitotically to produce gametes?
Options
1
Male honeybees
2
Male grasshoppers
3
Male earthworms
4
Female honeybees
Correct Answer
Male honeybees
Solution
1

Male honeybees (drones) develop from unfertilised eggs — they are haploid (n=16).

Meiosis requires 2n cells (to divide and halve chromosomes). Haploid cells CANNOT undergo meiosis.

2

Therefore drone spermatocytes undergo MITOSIS to produce haploid sperm.

All sperm from one drone are genetically identical (no meiosis = no crossing over).

Other options: male grasshoppers, earthworms are diploid → normal meiosis. Female honeybees are diploid → meiosis.

Male honeybees = haploid (n) → produce sperm by MITOSIS
Cannot do meiosis — already haploid! Unique feature of haplodiploid system.
Theory: Genetics
1. Haplodiploid Sex Determination in Honeybees

Honeybees (Apis mellifera) exemplify haplodiploidy — one of the most fascinating sex determination systems. Females (queens and workers): diploid (2n = 32). Develop from fertilised eggs (sperm + egg). Queens: reproductive females, fed royal jelly throughout larval development, lay up to 2000 eggs/day. Workers: sterile females, fed royal jelly only for first 3 days then bee bread. Males (drones): haploid (n = 16). Develop from unfertilised eggs by parthenogenesis (arrhenotoky). No father — inherits ONLY the queen mother's genome. Cannot produce gametes by meiosis (already haploid). Instead: haploid spermatocytes divide by mitosis to produce haploid sperm. All sperm from one drone are genetically identical. Sole function: mating with a virgin queen during nuptial flight. Die immediately after mating (genitalia torn away).

2. Why Meiosis is Impossible in Haploid Cells

Meiosis is specifically designed to halve the chromosome number from 2n to n. Meiosis I (reductional division): HOMOLOGOUS CHROMOSOME pairs align → one of each pair goes to each daughter cell → chromosome number halved (2n → n). For meiosis I to work: chromosomes must come in pairs (homologous pairs). Haploid cells (like drone spermatocytes): have ONLY ONE of each chromosome — no homologous partner. Meiosis I cannot occur (no pairs to separate). Meiosis II: division of sister chromatids (like mitosis). Even if meiosis II could occur in a haploid cell, the result would be cells with half the haploid chromosome number — non-viable. Therefore: haploid cells can ONLY divide by mitosis. Mitosis: each chromatid goes to a daughter cell → same chromosome number (n → n). All resulting cells are haploid and genetically identical (no crossing over).

3. Parthenogenesis — Types and Examples

Parthenogenesis: development from unfertilised egg without fertilisation. Types: Arrhenotoky: unfertilised eggs → males (haploid). Most common. Examples: all Hymenoptera (honeybees, wasps, ants). Thelytoky: unfertilised eggs → females. Examples: some ant species, some bee species, Komodo dragon, some sharks and rays. Deuterotoky: unfertilised eggs → both males and females. Examples: some insects, some crustaceans. Natural examples: Bdelloid rotifers (obligate parthenogenesis — no sexual reproduction). Parthenogenetic lizards (Cnemidophorus, Aspidoscelis in North America — all-female species). Water flea (Daphnia): alternates between sexual and parthenogenetic reproduction. Artificial parthenogenesis: inducing development with chemicals or physical stimuli (heat, pressure). Used in experimental embryology. Some IVF-related techniques. Significance: allows rapid population growth when mates are unavailable, reduces genetic recombination.

4. Kin Selection and Eusociality

Haplodiploidy has evolutionary consequences for kin selection and the evolution of worker sterility. Coefficients of relatedness (r) in honeybees (assuming same mother AND same father): Worker to full sister: r = 0.75 (extraordinary high). Why? Father (drone) has haploid genome → ALL his sperm are genetically identical. Daughters of same drone share 100% of paternal genome (not just 50% as in diploid organisms). Plus 50% maternal genome shared on average. Total: 0.5 x 0.5 + 0.5 x 1.0 = 0.75. Worker to own offspring: r = 0.5 (normal). Since workers are 0.75 related to sisters but only 0.5 to own offspring: it makes evolutionary sense (via Hamilton's rule: rb > c) for workers to be sterile and raise sisters rather than reproduce themselves. This haplodiploidy hypothesis for eusociality was proposed by W.D. Hamilton (1964). Note: eusociality also evolved in termites (diploid) — haplodiploidy not sufficient or necessary, just facilitating.

5. Comparison with Other Sex Determination Systems

Different organisms use very different mechanisms to determine sex: XX-XY (humans, Drosophila): sex determined by specific sex chromosomes. Males produce X and Y sperm (normal meiosis). XX-XO (grasshoppers): females XX, males XO. Males produce X and nullo-X sperm (normal meiosis). ZW-ZZ (birds, butterflies): females ZW, males ZZ. Normal meiosis in both sexes. Haplodiploid (honeybees, all Hymenoptera): sex determined by ploidy. Males haploid (produce sperm by mitosis), females diploid (produce eggs by meiosis). Temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD): crocodiles, turtles, some lizards. No sex chromosomes. Temperature during incubation determines sex. Incubation temperature → enzyme activity → hormone levels → gonadal differentiation. For NEET: the key fact about honeybees is that males (drones) are haploid and therefore produce gametes by MITOSIS not meiosis.

6. Gametogenesis — Mitosis vs Meiosis

In most sexually reproducing diploid organisms: gametogenesis involves meiosis to produce haploid gametes. Male animals (spermatogenesis): Spermatogonia (2n) → mitosis → primary spermatocytes (2n) → meiosis I → secondary spermatocytes (n) → meiosis II → spermatids (n) → spermiogenesis → sperm (n). Female animals (oogenesis): Oogonia (2n) → mitosis → primary oocytes (2n) → meiosis I → secondary oocyte (n) + 1st polar body → meiosis II → ovum (n) + 2nd polar body. Exception — honeybee drones: Spermatocytes (n) → MITOSIS → spermatids (n) → spermiogenesis → sperm (n). This is the only natural example in well-known animals where gametes are produced by mitosis. Key distinction: meiosis in diploid organisms → genetic diversity through crossing over and random assortment. Mitosis in haploid drones → all sperm genetically identical (no variation).

7. Colony Structure and Communication

Honeybee colony is a superorganism with ~50,000 workers, one queen, few hundred drones. Communication: waggle dance (discovered by Karl von Frisch, Nobel 1973): a figure-eight dance performed by forager bees on the honeycomb. The angle of the waggle run relative to vertical = direction of food source relative to the sun. Duration of waggle run = distance to food source. Round dance: food source close (<50 m). Pheromone communication: queen mandibular pheromone (QMP) suppresses worker ovary development and worker queen-rearing behaviour. Alarm pheromone (isoamyl acetate): from sting gland → recruits defenders. Nasonov pheromone: orientation and recruitment. Division of labour by age: nurse bees (days 1-12), house bees (days 12-21), guard bees, forager bees (day 21+). Thermoregulation: workers maintain hive temperature at 35-38°C by fanning or clustering. Honey production: foragers collect nectar → pass to house bees → add enzymes → evaporate water → seal with wax.

8. Genetic Consequences of Haplodiploidy

Haplodiploidy has important genetic consequences: Exposure of recessive alleles: in haploid males, ALL genes are expressed (no masking by dominant allele). Deleterious recessive mutations immediately visible to selection → rapidly eliminated. This may explain why drone populations have been proposed to have cleaner genomes. No sex-linked recessive inheritance pattern: X-linked recessives are more common in diploid male insects (like Drosophila where X-linked recessives are expressed in hemizygous males). In haploid honeybee males: ALL genes expressed regardless of chromosome of origin. Polyandry in queen: queen mates with 10-20 drones during nuptial flight → multiple patrilines in worker force → increased genetic diversity despite haplodiploidy → greater colony resilience. Worker patriline diversity benefits: different patrilines have different disease resistance genes, different temperature preferences → colony better able to respond to varied challenges. This is the proposed adaptive reason for queen polyandry.

Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why cannot male grasshoppers produce gametes by mitosis?
Male grasshoppers use XX-XO sex determination. Males are XO with 23 chromosomes (22 autosomes + 1 X). Despite having one fewer sex chromosome, males are still DIPLOID (2n=23). All their somatic cells are diploid. They undergo normal spermatogenesis: Primary spermatocytes (2n=23) → meiosis I → secondary spermatocytes (n = 11 or 12) → meiosis II → spermatids (n) → sperm. Meiosis I is slightly unusual (X chromosome unpaired, goes to only one pole) but still genuine meiosis. Contrast with honeybee drones which are genuinely haploid (n=16, not 2n) → cannot do meiosis at all.
2. What is arrhenotoky?
Arrhenotoky (Greek: arren = male, tokos = birth) is a type of parthenogenesis where unfertilised eggs develop into males. It is the most common type of parthenogenesis. Found in all Hymenoptera (bees, wasps, ants). In honeybees: queen can selectively fertilise eggs. Unfertilised eggs → haploid male drones (arrhenotoky). Fertilised eggs → diploid females (queens or workers depending on diet). This allows the queen to control the sex ratio of offspring based on colony needs. In early spring: more drones produced (for mating season). When colony needs workers: more fertilised eggs.
3. Are all species in Hymenoptera haplodiploid?
Yes, all species in the order Hymenoptera are haplodiploid. Hymenoptera includes: Bees (Apidae: Apis mellfera, Bombus, Trigona). Wasps (Vespidae: Vespula, Polistes; Sphecidae; Ichneumonidae). Ants (Formicidae: all ~20,000 species). Sawflies (Symphyta). Over 150,000 described Hymenoptera species. All use haplodiploidy. The single origin of haplodiploidy in the ancestral Hymenoptera and its retention across all descendants strongly suggests it has adaptive advantages. Haplodiploidy has also evolved independently in other groups: some thrips (Thysanoptera), some beetles, some mites. These independent origins are called convergent evolution of haplodiploidy.
4. How does the honeybee queen control offspring sex?
The queen controls sex through selective fertilisation. She stores sperm from her mating flights in her spermatheca (a specialised storage organ). When laying eggs: she can control the spermathecal sphincter muscle. Open sphincter → sperm released → fertilises egg → diploid → female development. Closed sphincter → no sperm → unfertilised egg → haploid → male development. The queen makes this decision based on the cell she is laying in. Worker cells and queen cells: queen lays fertilised eggs → diploid female development. Drone cells: queen lays unfertilised eggs → haploid male development. She can sense the cell size with her front legs before depositing an egg. A queen can lay 1000-2000 eggs per day for 3-5 years, making this a remarkably precise and sustained reproductive process.
5. What are the adaptive advantages of haplodiploidy?
Haplodiploidy offers several proposed evolutionary advantages: (1) Rapid purging of deleterious recessives: all genes in haploid males are expressed → harmful recessive alleles immediately exposed to natural selection and eliminated → cleaner gene pool. (2) Facilitation of eusociality: high relatedness between sisters (r=0.75) → kin selection favours worker altruism → eusociality evolves more readily. (3) Sex ratio flexibility: queen controls sex ratio by choosing to fertilise or not → colony can produce more workers or more drones as needed. (4) Genomic conflict reduction: cytoplasmic elements (mitochondria, Wolbachia) typically favour female offspring → in diploid XX/XY: conflict with nuclear genes. In haplo-diploid: different dynamics, possibly less conflict. Whether haplodiploidy CAUSED eusociality or just facilitated it is debated — termites (diploid) are also eusocial.
Previous Questions
Q.
Match gout rheumatoid arthritis osteoporosis osteoarthritis
Human Physiology · Answer: A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV
Q.
Match drugs nicotine morphine heroin cocaine with effects
Human Health · Answer: A-II, B-III, C-IV, D-I
Q.
WBC count 8000 eosinophils lymphocytes calculation per cu.mm
Human Physiology · Answer: 160-240 and 1600-2000/cu.mm
Q.
Grasshopper 23 and 24 chromosomes males females XX-XO
Genetics · Answer: 23=Males, 24=Females
Q.
Osteichthyes fishes flying fish angel fish fighting fish
Animal Kingdom · Answer: Flying fish, Angel fish, Fighting fish