Home › Biology › Q
BiologyMolecular Biology
Statement I: DNA replication is semi-conservative - each daughter DNA has one parental strand and one newly synthesised strand.
Statement II: Meselson and Stahl experiment used radioactive labelling with 32P to prove semi-conservative replication.
Options
1
Both I and II are correct
2
Statement I is correct and II is incorrect
3
Statement I is incorrect and II is correct
4
Both I and II are incorrect
Correct Answer
Statement I is correct and II is incorrect
Solution
1

Statement I: Semi-conservative = one parental + one new strand in each daughter DNA. TRUE

2

Statement II: Meselson-Stahl used 15N/14N density labelling + CsCl gradient centrifugation.

NOT radioactive 32P! Statement II is FALSE.

Answer: Statement I correct, II incorrect

Meselson-Stahl: 15N/14N density difference + CsCl centrifugation (NOT 32P)
Statement I: TRUE | Statement II: FALSE
Theory: Molecular Biology
1. Semi-Conservative DNA Replication

Watson and Crick (1953) proposed that DNA replication would be semi-conservative: each strand of the double helix serves as template for synthesis of new complementary strand. Result: two daughter DNA molecules, each with one original (parental) strand and one new strand. Three models proposed: Conservative: original double helix remains intact, both new strands form new molecule. Semi-conservative: each daughter has one old + one new strand. Dispersive: original DNA fragmented and distributed throughout both daughter molecules. Meselson and Stahl (1958): proved semi-conservative model using 15N/14N isotope labelling in E. coli. This is considered one of the most beautiful experiments in biology.

2. Meselson-Stahl Experiment (1958)

Grew E. coli in 15N (heavy nitrogen) medium for many generations: all DNA labelled heavy (15N-15N). Transferred to 14N (normal) medium. Extracted DNA at various time points. Centrifuged in CsCl (caesium chloride) density gradient. After 1 generation: single band at intermediate density = hybrid (15N-14N) = semi-conservative prediction confirmed. Both parental strands separated; each served as template; each got paired with new 14N strand. After 2 generations: two bands - half hybrid + half light (14N-14N). After 3 generations: 1/4 hybrid + 3/4 light. This pattern only possible with semi-conservative replication. Rules out conservative (would give heavy + light after 1st generation). Rules out dispersive (would give single band gradually shifting from heavy to light).

3. DNA Replication Machinery

Replication fork: point where double helix is unwound and replicated. Origin of replication (ori): specific sequence where replication begins. E. coli has 1 ori (oriC). Eukaryotes: multiple origins (fired simultaneously to replicate large genome quickly). Enzymes: Helicase: unwinds double helix (breaks H-bonds). Single-strand binding proteins (SSBPs): stabilise single-stranded DNA. Topoisomerase: relieves tension ahead of replication fork (prevents supercoiling). Primase: synthesises short RNA primer (DNA polymerase cannot start de novo). DNA polymerase III (E. coli): main replicating enzyme. Extends 5 to 3 only, needs primer, proofreading (3 to 5 exonuclease). DNA polymerase I: removes RNA primers (5 to 3 exonuclease), fills gap (5 to 3 polymerase). DNA ligase: seals nicks between Okazaki fragments.

4. Leading and Lagging Strand Synthesis

Replication fork moves in one direction. DNA polymerase only works 5 to 3. Template strands antiparallel. Leading strand: template oriented 3 to 5 in direction of fork movement. DNA pol synthesises continuously 5 to 3 (same direction as fork). One primer needed. Lagging strand: template oriented 5 to 3 in direction of fork movement. DNA pol must work in opposite direction (away from fork). Discontinuous synthesis: Okazaki fragments (1000-2000 nt in prokaryotes; 100-200 nt in eukaryotes). Each fragment needs primer. After fragment completed: DNA pol I removes primer, fills gap. DNA ligase joins fragments. Net result: same replication speed on both strands due to "trombone" model - lagging strand loops back.

5. Replication Fidelity and Repair

Replication error rate: ~1 error per 10^5 to 10^6 nucleotides (initial). After proofreading: 1 per 10^7. After mismatch repair: 1 per 10^9 to 10^10. 3 fidelity mechanisms: Base selection: Watson-Crick base pairing - only correct base fits properly in active site. Proofreading: 3 to 5 exonuclease activity of DNA pol III detects mismatched base, excises it, replication re-tries. Mismatch repair: MutS detects mismatch, MutL and MutH recruited, newly synthesised strand cut and resynthesised correctly. DNA damage repair: base excision repair (BER), nucleotide excision repair (NER - removes thymine dimers from UV damage), homologous recombination repair. BRCA1/BRCA2 mutations: impair double-strand break repair, increase breast/ovarian cancer risk.

6. Telomeres and Telomerase

Telomeres: repetitive DNA at chromosome ends (TTAGGG repeats in humans, ~5-10 kb). Protect chromosome ends from: degradation, fusion, recognition as double-strand breaks. End-replication problem: DNA polymerase cannot completely replicate the very end of a linear chromosome (needs primer that would extend beyond the end). Each replication cycle: telomeres shorten by ~50-200 bp. After ~50-70 divisions: telomeres critically short = senescence (Hayflick limit). Telomerase: reverse transcriptase enzyme with built-in RNA template. Extends 3 end of chromosome using RNA template. Adds TTAGGG repeats. Active in: germ cells (eggs, sperm), stem cells, embryonic cells. Inactive in most somatic cells. Cancer cells: activate telomerase = immortalised (can divide indefinitely). Telomere length = molecular clock. Werner syndrome, Dyskeratosis congenita: premature aging from telomere dysfunction.

7. Types of DNA

A-form DNA: right-handed helix, 11 bp per turn, shorter and wider. Formed in dehydrated conditions or in RNA:DNA hybrid duplexes. B-form DNA: right-handed, 10 bp per turn, 3.4 Angstrom pitch per bp. Most common in cells. Z-form DNA: left-handed helix, 12 bp per turn. Found in regions of alternating purine-pyrimidine (GC repeats). May regulate transcription. Supercoiling: torsional stress in DNA. Positive supercoiling: overwound ahead of replication fork. Negative supercoiling: underwound, allows strand separation. Topoisomerases: relieve supercoiling. Topoisomerase I: cut one strand, rotate, reseal (no ATP needed). Topoisomerase II: cut both strands, pass other segment through, reseal (ATP-dependent). Quinolone antibiotics (ciprofloxacin): inhibit bacterial DNA gyrase (type II topoisomerase). Camptothecin: inhibits eukaryotic Top I (cancer drug).

8. DNA Damage and Mutations

DNA damage causes: UV radiation: thymine dimers (T-T covalent bonds). Repaired by NER (nucleotide excision repair) or photoreactivation (in some organisms, photolyase enzyme). X-rays/gamma rays: double-strand breaks. Repaired by homologous recombination or non-homologous end joining (NHEJ). Chemical mutagens: alkylating agents (EMS, MNNG): add methyl/ethyl to bases. Intercalating agents (acridine): cause frameshift. Base analogues (5-BU): incorporated instead of T, causes transition mutations. Deamination: C to U (spontaneous, repaired by uracil-DNA glycosylase). Depurination: loss of purine base (spontaneous, causes AP site). Oxidative damage: 8-oxoguanine (pairs with A instead of C). Repaired by BER. Translesion synthesis: specialised DNA polymerases (pol eta, pol zeta) bypass lesions. Error-prone but allows survival.

Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why did Meselson-Stahl use 15N instead of radioactive 32P for labelling? ⌄
Meselson and Stahl needed to SEPARATE DNA molecules based on their labelling pattern - not just detect radioactivity. Using 15N (heavy nitrogen): 15N-15N DNA is denser than 14N-14N DNA. This density difference allows PHYSICAL SEPARATION by centrifugation in CsCl gradient. DNA molecules literally sit at different positions in the gradient tube based on their density. After UV illumination, you can SEE three possible bands: heavy (15N-15N), hybrid (15N-14N), and light (14N-14N). Using 32P: radioactivity cannot be used to physically separate DNA molecules by density. All DNA molecules would be mixed together, detectable only by radioactivity counting. You cannot distinguish 32P-32P from 32P-31P from 31P-31P molecules by where they sit in a gradient. So 15N density labelling was essential for the experimental logic - it allowed direct visualization of parental vs hybrid vs new DNA molecules.
2. How does the semi-conservative model explain the Meselson-Stahl results? ⌄
Semi-conservative prediction: Generation 0 (all 15N): all DNA heavy = one band at bottom. Generation 1 (transfer to 14N): each parental strand serves as template. New strand = 14N. Each daughter molecule = 15N (template) + 14N (new) = HYBRID. One band at intermediate position (no heavy, no light bands). This is exactly what was observed. Generation 2: hybrid molecules replicate. 15N strand serves as template = new 14N strand = hybrid again. 14N strand serves as template = new 14N strand = light (14N-14N). Result: 50% hybrid + 50% light = TWO BANDS (intermediate + light). Exactly observed. Conservative prediction would have given: Gen 1 = heavy band + light band (two bands, no hybrid). Dispersive would have given: single band shifting from heavy toward light over generations.
3. What is the end-replication problem and how does telomerase solve it? ⌄
End-replication problem: DNA polymerase requires a primer to start synthesis and can only extend in 5 to 3 direction. At the very end of a linear chromosome (3 end of template strand), after the RNA primer is removed, there is no upstream sequence to prime synthesis of the last few nucleotides. The complementary strand cannot be completed. Result: chromosomes shorten by the length of one RNA primer (~10-20 nt) after every round of replication. Over ~50 cell divisions, this adds up to significant shortening. Telomerase solves this: it is a reverse transcriptase with a built-in RNA template (the sequence AAUCCC or similar complementary to TTAGGG). It binds to the 3-OH overhang at chromosome end, uses its RNA template, extends the 3 end by adding more TTAGGG repeats. This extension then allows primase to synthesise a primer further out, DNA pol fills in, and the chromosome end is partially restored. Not perfect - telomeres still shorten slowly over lifetime.
4. What are the key differences between prokaryotic and eukaryotic DNA replication? ⌄
Prokaryotic (E. coli): one circular chromosome, single origin of replication (oriC), replication takes ~40 min, DNA pol III is main replicating enzyme (~900 nt/sec). Eukaryotic: multiple linear chromosomes, thousands of origins of replication fired simultaneously (allows ~8 hours total S phase despite much larger genome), multiple DNA polymerases: pol alpha (primase activity, starts replication), pol delta (main lagging strand enzyme), pol epsilon (leading strand). DNA polymerase cannot start de novo = needs primase. Chromatin context: histone octamers disassembled ahead of fork, reassembled on daughter strands. Both H3-H4 tetramers and H2A-H2B dimers recycled onto daughter strands. Epigenetic marks (histone modifications) also replicated to maintain gene expression patterns. Licensing system: ORC (Origin Recognition Complex) + MCM helicase complex loaded at origins. Licensed once per cell cycle = prevents re-replication.
5. What is the significance of DNA proofreading in maintaining genomic integrity? ⌄
DNA pol III proofreading: 3 to 5 exonuclease activity detects and removes incorrectly paired nucleotides before extending further. Base pairing fidelity: only correct nucleotide fits properly in the active site due to geometric constraints. Wrong nucleotide slightly misshapen = poor fit = slower catalysis = removed by proofreading. Error rates: Without proofreading (just base selection): ~10^-5 errors per base. With proofreading: ~10^-7. With mismatch repair added: ~10^-9 to 10^-10. Human genome: 3.2 billion base pairs. Without proofreading: ~32,000 mutations per cell division. With all repair systems: ~1-2 mutations per cell division (mostly neutral). Over lifetime: ~10^16 cell divisions. Accumulated mutations in somatic cells contribute to aging and cancer. Cancer: multiple mutations in proto-oncogenes and tumour suppressor genes accumulate over decades. Defects in repair genes (BRCA1/2, MLH1, MSH2) dramatically increase mutation rate and cancer risk.
Previous Questions
Q.
George Gamow proposed triplet genetic code 4^3=64 codons 20 amino acids
Biology . George Gamow
Q.
Mendel classical experiments Pisum sativum garden pea inheritance genetics
Biology . Pisum sativum
Q.
Sexual reproduction features gamete fusion meiosis genetic variation B C D only
Biology . B, C and D only
Q.
Flower parts stigma anther style ovary match A-III B-I C-II D-IV
Biology . A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV
Q.
Asexual reproduction Planaria regeneration binary fission budding sporulation
Biology . Regeneration in Planaria