HomeBiology › Q
BiologyAnimal Kingdom / Echinodermata
Given below are two statements about Echinodermata:
Statement I: They are triploblastic and have a true coelom.
Statement II: They show radial symmetry in the larval stage.
In the light of the above statements, choose the most appropriate answer:
Options
1
Both Statement I and Statement II are correct
2
Statement I is correct but Statement II is incorrect
3
Statement I is incorrect but Statement II is correct
4
Both Statement I and Statement II are incorrect
Correct Answer
Statement I is correct but Statement II is incorrect
Solution
1

Statement I: Triploblastic + true coelom = TRUE ✓

Echinoderms have 3 germ layers and a true mesodermally-lined coelom.

2

Statement II: "Radial symmetry in LARVAL stage" = FALSE ✗

LARVAE are BILATERALLY symmetrical; ADULTS are radially (pentaradially) symmetrical.

Answer: Statement I correct, Statement II incorrect

Echinoderms: Adults = PENTARADIAL symmetry | Larvae = BILATERAL symmetry
Triploblastic + True coelom = TRUE | "Radial symmetry in larvae" = FALSE
Theory: Animal Kingdom / Echinodermata
1. Phylum Echinodermata — Overview

Echinodermata is a phylum of exclusively marine, bottom-dwelling (largely benthic) invertebrates that are among the most morphologically distinctive and evolutionarily significant animal groups. Approximately 7,000 living species are known, distributed across all ocean depths from the intertidal zone to hadal depths exceeding 10,000 metres. Despite their radically different adult body plan, echinoderms are deuterostomes — they share embryological development features (blastopore becoming the anus rather than the mouth, enterocoelic coelom formation, and radial/indeterminate cleavage) with chordates, making echinoderms the invertebrate phylum most closely related to the vertebrates. This evolutionary relationship, rather counter-intuitive given the starfish's apparent distance from any vertebrate, is strongly supported by molecular phylogenetic evidence and explains why echinoderms are studied as outgroup models in evolutionary developmental biology research on chordate body plan origins.

2. Key Characteristics of Echinodermata

Exclusively marine: no freshwater or terrestrial echinoderms exist. Triploblastic eucoelomate: three embryonic germ layers (ectoderm, mesoderm, endoderm) and a true coelom (enterocoel, formed from outpockets of the archenteron/primitive gut during development). Endoskeleton: calcite (calcium carbonate) ossicles embedded in the dermis, often bearing spines that project through the epidermis (explaining the phylum name "spiny skin"). Water vascular system: hydraulic system for locomotion and feeding, unique to echinoderms. Pentaradial symmetry in adults: 5-fold (or multiples of 5) radial symmetry secondary derived from a bilateral ancestral condition. No head or distinct brain: nervous system is decentralised, with a nerve ring around the oesophagus and radial nerves extending into each arm/section. Remarkable regeneration ability: can regenerate lost arms and in some species the entire body from a single arm plus part of the central disc. Separate sexes (mostly): most echinoderms have separate male and female individuals with external fertilisation.

3. Larval Forms — Bilateral Symmetry to Pentaradial Adults

The transformation from bilaterally symmetrical larvae to pentaradially symmetrical adults is one of the most remarkable developmental transitions in the animal kingdom, representing a fundamental reorganisation of the entire body plan during metamorphosis. Starfish (Asteroidea): fertilised egg → Bipinnaria larva (elongated, bilaterally symmetrical, ciliated, free-swimming) → Brachiolaria larva (larger bipinnaria with additional adhesive organ for settlement) → settles and metamorphoses into juvenile starfish with pentaradial symmetry. Sea urchin (Echinoidea): egg → Pluteus larva (bilaterally symmetrical, transparent, with skeletal rods giving a tripod-like appearance) → metamorphosis into juvenile urchin. Sea cucumber (Holothuroidea): egg → Auricularia larva → Doliolaria larva → metamorphosis. Sea lily (Crinoidea): egg → Doliolaria larva → Cystidean larva → adult sea lily. The transition from bilateral to radial symmetry during metamorphosis likely reflects the evolutionary history of the phylum — echinoderms evolved from bilaterally symmetrical ancestors (as evidenced by their bilaterally symmetrical larvae and their deuterostome relationships), with the pentaradial symmetry of the adult representing a derived, secondary condition that evolved in association with their sessile or slow-moving bottom-dwelling lifestyle.

4. Classes of Echinodermata

Five living classes are recognised: Asteroidea (sea stars/starfish): flat, star-shaped with 5 or more arms; tube feet with suckers; carnivores that can evert their stomach to digest prey externally. Examples: Asterias, Pentaceros. Ophiuroidea (brittle stars): similar to starfish but with distinct central disc and long, snake-like arms that move by lateral bending (unlike sea stars' tube feet locomotion); largely detrivores/filter feeders. Examples: Ophiothrix. Echinoidea (sea urchins and sand dollars): body enclosed in rigid test (fused ossicle plates); movable spines; tube feet for locomotion; well-developed Aristotle's lantern (chewing apparatus) in sea urchins. Examples: Echinus, Strongylocentrotus. Holothuroidea (sea cucumbers): elongated body along oral-aboral axis; no arms; ossicles small and scattered (body feels leathery); can eviscerate when threatened. Examples: Holothuria, Cucumaria. Crinoidea (sea lilies and feather stars): considered the most primitive living class; stalked (sea lilies) or free-moving (feather stars); arms are feathery and used for filter feeding. Examples: Antedon, Ptilocrinus.

Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why is the larval bilateral symmetry of echinoderms considered evidence for their evolutionary origin from bilaterally symmetrical ancestors?
The bilateral symmetry of echinoderm larvae provides compelling evidence for the evolutionary history of this phylum within the broader context of animal body plan evolution, and is one of the most cited examples of how larval morphology can preserve evolutionary ancestral features (a concept sometimes called "ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny" or Haeckel's biogenetic law, though this principle is now understood in a more nuanced way). Echinoderms are grouped with chordates and hemichordates in the clade Deuterostomia, based on shared embryological development features. Deuterostome common ancestors were almost certainly bilaterally symmetrical, as bilateral symmetry is ancestral for bilaterians (the broad animal grouping including all organisms with bilateral symmetry, which represents the ancestral condition from which radial symmetry has evolved independently multiple times, including in adult echinoderms, cnidarians, and some other groups). The persistence of bilateral symmetry in echinoderm larvae, with radial symmetry appearing only during the metamorphic transition to the adult form, strongly suggests that bilateral symmetry represents the ancestral developmental program conserved from the bilaterally symmetrical ancestors of the echinoderm lineage, while pentaradial adult symmetry represents a derived evolutionary innovation that developed specifically in the echinoderm lineage in association with their particular lifestyle and ecology. The molecular developmental evidence supports this interpretation: genes controlling bilateral body axis formation (including genes homologous to those establishing anterior-posterior and dorsal-ventral axes in bilaterally symmetrical animals) are expressed during echinoderm larval development, with the transition to radial adult symmetry requiring active reprogramming of these developmental signals during metamorphosis, further confirming that bilateral symmetry is indeed the ancestral developmental state for echinoderms despite their radially symmetrical adult morphology.
Previous Questions
Q.
Prokaryote eukaryote fungi mycoplasma nostoc anabaena cyanobacteria not prokaryote
Biology . Fungi
Q.
Plasmogamy karyogamy meiosis fungi match protoplast fusion nuclei reduction division
Biology . A-II, B-III, C-I
Q.
Sphenopsida Equisetum horsetail pteridophyta bryophyta gymnospermae
Biology . Pteridophyta
Q.
Photosynthesis history Priestley Ingenhousz Sachs Senebier first experiment
Biology . Priestley showed role of air
Q.
Frog cranial nerve pairs 10 human 12 accessory hypoglossal vertebrate
Biology . 10