Home › Chemistry › Q
ChemistrySolutions / Colligative Properties

Assertion (A): An ideal solution has zero enthalpy of mixing.
Reason (R): In an ideal solution, the interactions between solute-solvent molecules are weaker than those between solute-solute and solvent-solvent molecules.
Choose the most appropriate answer:

R
Solution written and verified by Roshan, science educator with 5 years of experience teaching NEET and JEE aspirants. Last reviewed September 2026.
Options
1
Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
2
Both A and R are true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A
3
A is true but R is false
4
Both A and R are false
Correct Answer
A is true but R is false
Solution
1

A: Ideal solution has delta H_mix = 0 → TRUE ✓

2

R: "Solute-solvent interactions WEAKER than solute-solute/solvent-solvent" = condition for POSITIVE DEVIATION (not ideal) → FALSE ✗

Ideal solution: A-B = A-A = B-B interactions (all equal)

Answer: A is true but R is false

Ideal: delta_H_mix = 0 BECAUSE A-B = A-A = B-B interactions (all equal)
R describes positive deviation (A-B < A-A, B-B) NOT ideal solution
Theory: Solutions / Colligative Properties
1. Ideal Solutions — Thermodynamic Treatment

An ideal solution is one in which the chemical potential of each component is given by mu_i = mu_i* + RT ln(x_i), where mu_i* is the standard chemical potential (chemical potential of pure component i) and x_i is the mole fraction. This relationship, which is the thermodynamic statement of Raoult's law, implies that the mixing of ideal solution components is accompanied by: delta_G_mix = RT(n1 ln x1 + n2 ln x2) — always negative for any mixing (since all x_i < 1 and all ln x_i < 0), meaning the process of mixing is always spontaneous for ideal solutions. delta_S_mix = -R(n1 ln x1 + n2 ln x2) — always positive, reflecting the increase in entropy when two components intermingle. delta_H_mix = 0 — by definition, since all intermolecular interactions (A-A, B-B, A-B) are identical, no energy is released or absorbed during mixing. delta_V_mix = 0 — no volume change on mixing, since the molar volumes of the components are additive. These conditions are satisfied only when the components are structurally and energetically very similar: same molecular size and shape (so that one molecule can substitute for another in the liquid structure without energetic penalty), same type of intermolecular interactions (so that A-B, A-A, and B-B interactions are all equal). In practice, perfect ideal solutions do not exist, but pairs like benzene-toluene, hexane-heptane, and optical enantiomers approach ideal behaviour very closely.

2. Positive and Negative Deviations from Raoult's Law

Real solutions deviate from ideal behaviour when the intermolecular interactions between different molecular species (A-B interactions) differ from the interactions between like species (A-A or B-B interactions). These deviations are classified as positive or negative depending on whether the vapour pressure of the solution is higher or lower than the ideal (Raoult's law) prediction. Positive deviation: total vapour pressure > P_Raoult = x1*P1* + x2*P2*. Condition: A-B interactions < A-A and B-B interactions. Physical reason: molecules in the mixture have fewer and/or weaker intermolecular interactions than in the pure components, so they escape more readily to the vapour phase. Thermodynamics: delta_H_mix > 0 (endothermic, energy must be absorbed to break the relatively stronger A-A and B-B interactions). delta_V_mix > 0 (slight expansion, molecules pack less efficiently in the mixture). Typical examples: acetone-carbon disulfide (dipole-dipole vs London forces mismatch), ethanol-cyclohexane, water-methanol (at some compositions). Negative deviation: total vapour pressure < P_Raoult. Condition: A-B interactions > A-A and B-B interactions. Physical reason: molecules are more strongly attracted to each other in the mixture, escape less readily to vapour phase. Thermodynamics: delta_H_mix < 0 (exothermic, heat released as stronger A-B interactions form). delta_V_mix < 0 (slight contraction, molecules pack more efficiently). Examples: acetone-chloroform (strong H-bond from CHCl3 H to C=O of acetone), water-sulfuric acid (strongly exothermic mixing, violent if concentrated H2SO4 added to water), HCl/HNO3/HBr-water (gas dissolves with formation of strong A-B interactions).

3. Colligative Properties — Full Derivation and Application

Colligative properties are thermodynamic consequences of the Raoult's law lowering of solvent chemical potential upon adding a non-volatile solute. The addition of n2 moles of non-volatile solute to n1 moles of solvent lowers the chemical potential of the solvent from mu1* to mu1 = mu1* + RT ln x1 = mu1* + RT ln(1-x2). For dilute solutions: x2 << 1, so ln(1-x2) ≈ -x2, and the chemical potential lowering = RT*x2. From this fundamental lowering of solvent chemical potential, all four colligative properties can be derived. Vapour pressure lowering: the vapour pressure of the solvent above the solution is lower (P1 = x1*P1* < P1*), and (P1*-P1)/P1* = x2 (relative lowering of vapour pressure = mole fraction of solute). Boiling point elevation: the boiling point is raised because the solvent chemical potential must equal the vapour (steam) chemical potential at boiling — since the solvent chemical potential is lowered by x2, a higher temperature is needed. delta_Tb = (R*T_b^2*M1)/(1000*delta_vap H) * m = Kb*m, where Kb is the ebullioscopic constant. For water: Kb = 0.512 K kg/mol. Freezing point depression: the freezing point is depressed because the chemical potential of solid solvent (independent of solution composition) must equal the liquid solvent chemical potential — since the latter is lowered, equilibrium is achieved at lower temperature. delta_Tf = Kf*m. For water: Kf = 1.86 K kg/mol. Osmotic pressure: for a semi-permeable membrane permeable to solvent but not solute, osmotic pressure pi = MRT (van't Hoff equation, analogous to PV = nRT for gases). The osmotic pressure is by far the most sensitive colligative property for high molecular weight substances.

4. Anomalous Molar Masses from Colligative Properties

One of the most powerful applications of colligative property measurements is the determination of the molar mass of unknown solutes — but the measured molar mass (apparent molar mass) can differ significantly from the true molar mass for two important categories of solutes: electrolytes and association-prone solutes. For electrolytes (dissociate into multiple ions): the observed colligative effect is larger than predicted for the undissociated solute because each mole of electrolyte produces more than one mole of dissolved particles. The measured apparent molar mass is therefore SMALLER than the true formula mass. Examples: KCl (M = 74.5 g/mol) completely dissociated gives i = 2, so apparent M from freezing point depression = 74.5/2 = 37.25 g/mol. MgSO4 (M = 120.4) in dilute solution gives i slightly less than 2 (due to ion pairing), apparent M ≈ 65 g/mol. The van't Hoff factor i = true molar mass / apparent molar mass = observed colligative effect / expected (without dissociation). For association (molecules dimerize or form higher aggregates): the number of dissolved particles is LESS than expected for complete dissociation, so the observed colligative effect is SMALLER than expected, and the apparent molar mass is LARGER than the true formula mass. Classic example: acetic acid dimerises in benzene solution through double hydrogen bonding: 2 CH3COOH ⇌ (CH3COOH)2. The apparent molar mass measured by freezing point depression of benzene solution approaches 120 g/mol (twice the formula mass of 60) at high concentrations, indicating nearly complete dimerisation. This anomalous behaviour allowed chemists to correctly identify the dimer structure of acetic acid in non-polar solvents.

5. Osmosis and Reverse Osmosis — Membrane Technology

Osmosis — the spontaneous flow of solvent through a semi-permeable membrane from a region of lower solute concentration (higher solvent chemical potential) to a region of higher solute concentration (lower solvent chemical potential) — is one of the most important phenomena in biology and has become the basis of major industrial water purification technologies. In biology: osmosis drives the absorption of water by plant roots from soil (the root cell sap has higher solute concentration than soil water), the reabsorption of water by kidney tubules, the movement of nutrients in the phloem of plants, and the maintenance of cell turgor pressure. Red blood cells undergo crenation (shrinkage) in hypertonic solution (higher concentration than blood = 0.9% NaCl) and lysis (bursting) in hypotonic solution (lower concentration than blood), demonstrating that osmotic pressure differences can generate large mechanical forces. Osmotic pressure of blood = ~7.5 atm. Reverse osmosis (RO): application of pressure greater than the osmotic pressure on the high-concentration side of the membrane forces water to flow from high concentration to low concentration (against the natural osmotic direction), effectively purifying the water. Modern RO membranes (thin-film composite polyamide membranes) can reject >99% of dissolved ions, bacteria, viruses, and organic molecules. Applications: desalination of seawater (osmotic pressure of seawater ≈ 27 atm, so applied pressure must exceed this — typically 55-70 atm is used to achieve practical flow rates). Also used in: water purification for drinking, food processing, pharmaceutical manufacturing, kidney dialysis.

6. Vapour Pressure and Distillation Principles

The vapour pressure of a solution and its temperature dependence determine the boiling behaviour and the possibility of separating liquid mixtures by distillation — one of the most important unit operations in chemical industry and laboratory practice. Simple distillation: works well when the two components have very different boiling points (>25°C difference) and the vapour is significantly enriched in the more volatile component. Fractional distillation: uses a fractionating column with multiple theoretical plates (each plate allows one equilibration between liquid and vapour) to achieve multiple successive vaporisation-condensation cycles, gradually enriching the vapour in the more volatile component and achieving clean separation. McCabe-Thiele diagrams: graphical method using vapour-liquid equilibrium (VLE) curves (y-x diagrams, where y = mole fraction in vapour, x = mole fraction in liquid at equilibrium) to determine the number of theoretical plates required for a given separation. Industrial distillation columns: petroleum refining uses massive distillation towers (up to 100 m tall with 50+ trays) to separate crude oil into fractions (LPG, gasoline/naphtha, kerosene, diesel, fuel oil, residue) by their boiling point ranges. Distillation is the world's most energy-intensive chemical engineering operation, consuming approximately 40% of the total energy used in the chemical process industries, providing strong motivation for development of more energy-efficient separation technologies such as membrane separation, adsorption, and crystallisation.

Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the conditions for an ideal solution? ⌄
An ideal solution follows Raoult's law at all compositions and temperatures. Conditions: (1) Forces between molecules of components A and B (A-B interactions) must be equal to the forces between like molecules (A-A and B-B interactions). (2) delta H_mix = 0 (no heat released or absorbed on mixing). (3) delta V_mix = 0 (no volume change on mixing). (4) Each component obeys Raoult's law: pi = xi*Pi_pure.
2. What is the difference between ideal and non-ideal solutions? ⌄
Ideal solution: delta H_mix = 0, delta V_mix = 0, obeys Raoult's law. Example: benzene-toluene, hexane-heptane (similar molecules). Non-ideal solutions: Positive deviation (A-B < A-A and B-B): delta H_mix > 0, total vapour pressure > Raoult prediction. Examples: acetone-CS2, ethanol-water. Negative deviation (A-B > A-A and B-B): delta H_mix < 0, total vapour pressure < Raoult prediction. Examples: chloroform-acetone (H-bonding), HCl-water, H2SO4-water.
3. What is Henry's law? ⌄
Henry's law: at constant temperature, the solubility of a gas in a liquid is directly proportional to the partial pressure of the gas above the liquid. p = KH × x, where p = partial pressure, KH = Henry's law constant, x = mole fraction of gas in solution. At low concentrations (dilute solution limit), Henry's law applies; at pure solvent limit, Raoult's law applies. For volatile solutes in dilute solutions: solute obeys Henry's law, solvent obeys Raoult's law.
4. Why is benzene-toluene considered an ideal solution? ⌄
Benzene (C6H6) and toluene (C6H5CH3) are structurally very similar — both aromatic, similar molecular size and shape, similar polarizability. Therefore, benzene-benzene, toluene-toluene, and benzene-toluene interactions are all essentially equal (similar London dispersion forces). This means mixing them produces no change in enthalpy (delta H_mix ≈ 0) and no change in volume (delta V_mix ≈ 0), and the solution obeys Raoult's law precisely. This is the closest approximation to an ideal solution found in practice.
5. What are azeotropes? ⌄
Azeotropes (constant boiling mixtures): solutions that boil at a constant temperature and have the same composition in liquid and vapour phases, making them impossible to separate further by simple distillation. Minimum boiling azeotrope (positive deviation): ethanol-water (95.6% EtOH, 78.1°C). Maximum boiling azeotrope (negative deviation): HNO3-water (68% HNO3, 120.5°C), HCl-water (20.2% HCl, 108.6°C).
Previous Questions
Q.
Tetraammineaquachloridocobalt III chloride formula Co NH3 4 H2O Cl Cl2 IUPAC coordination
Chemistry . [Co(NH3)4(H2O)Cl]Cl2
Q.
Oxidation state N2O5 Al2O3 H2S decreasing order N=+5 Al=+3 S=-2 redox
Chemistry . N2O5 > Al2O3 > H2S
Q.
Lanthanide 4 unpaired electrons Ho3+ 4f10 magnetic moment f-block rare earth configuration
Chemistry . Ho3+
Q.
KMnO4 titration K2C2O4 oxalate 0.10 M permanganometry equivalents n-factor volumetric
Chemistry . 0.10 M
Q.
Co(NH3)6 Cl3 1:3 electrolyte coordination compound dissociation counter ions Werner
Chemistry . [Co(NH3)6]Cl3