Home › Biology › Q
BiologyPhotosynthesis
Assertion (A): C4 plants have higher rates of photosynthesis than C3 plants under high temperature and light intensity.
Reason (R): C4 plants have a special mechanism (Hatch-Slack pathway) to concentrate CO2 around RuBisCO.
Options
1
Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
2
Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A
3
A is true but R is false
4
A is false but R is true
Correct Answer
Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
Solution
1

A: C4 plants have higher photosynthesis at high temp/light than C3 = TRUE

R: C4 Hatch-Slack pathway concentrates CO2 around RuBisCO in bundle sheath cells = TRUE

2

R explains A: concentrated CO2 suppresses photorespiration → higher net photosynthesis at high temperatures.

Answer: Both true, R explains A

C4 plants: Hatch-Slack pathway concentrates CO2 → suppresses photorespiration → more efficient at high temperatures
Theory: Photosynthesis
1. C3 vs C4 Photosynthesis

C3 plants: first stable product of CO2 fixation = 3-PGA (3 carbons). Enzyme: RuBisCO (ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase). All reactions in mesophyll cells. Subject to photorespiration (O2 competes with CO2 at RuBisCO). Examples: wheat, rice, barley, potato, sunflower, soybean, most trees. C4 plants: first stable product = OAA (oxaloacetate, 4 carbons). Dual cell system: mesophyll + bundle sheath. PEP carboxylase fixes CO2 in mesophyll. C4 acid (malate/aspartate) transported to bundle sheath. Decarboxylated - CO2 released and concentrated around RuBisCO. Calvin cycle runs in bundle sheath. Almost no photorespiration. Examples: maize, sugarcane, sorghum, Amaranthus, millet, Bermuda grass. C4 evolved ~30 times independently! CAM plants: CO2 fixation at night (PEP carboxylase). Stored as malate. Released and fixed by RuBisCO during day (stomata closed). Cacti, Agave, pineapple.

2. Light Reactions of Photosynthesis

Light reactions occur in thylakoid membranes. Photosystem II (PS II): absorbs 680 nm. P680 = reaction centre. Water splitting (photolysis): 2H2O → 4H+ + 4e- + O2. Electrons passed to plastoquinone (PQ). ATP synthesis: electrons flow through cytochrome b6f complex (proton gradient across thylakoid membrane drives ATP synthase). Cyclic photophosphorylation: PS I only. Only ATP produced (no NADPH, no O2). Photosystem I (PS I): absorbs 700 nm. P700 = reaction centre. Electrons + H+ + NADP+ → NADPH via ferredoxin + NADP reductase. Non-cyclic photophosphorylation (Z-scheme): both PS II and PS I. Produces ATP + NADPH + O2. Overall light reactions: 12 H2O + 12 NADP+ + 18 ADP + 18 Pi → 6 O2 + 12 NADPH + 18 ATP (per 1 glucose eventually produced). Chemiosmosis: proton gradient across thylakoid membrane (lumen acidic) drives ATP synthase (CF0-CF1 complex).

3. Calvin Cycle (Dark Reactions / C3 Cycle)

Calvin-Benson-Bassham cycle. Location: stroma of chloroplast. Three stages: Carboxylation: RuBisCO catalyses CO2 + RuBP (5C) → 2 molecules of 3-PGA (3C). Reduction: 3-PGA → G3P (glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate). Uses 2 ATP + 2 NADPH per PGA. Regeneration: G3P → RuBP. Uses 3 ATP per RuBP regenerated. Net: per 3 CO2 fixed: 9 ATP + 6 NADPH consumed, 1 G3P net output. Per glucose (6 CO2): 18 ATP + 12 NADPH. RuBisCO: most abundant protein on Earth (25% of leaf nitrogen). Slow enzyme (~3 CO2/sec vs typical enzyme ~1000/sec). Has both carboxylase and oxygenase activities. Oxygenase = photorespiration. CO2/O2 selectivity ratio ~80 (prefers CO2 80:1). But at high [O2] relative to [CO2] (high temperature, low CO2) → significant oxygenase activity.

4. Factors Affecting Photosynthesis

Light: rate increases with light intensity up to light saturation point. Beyond: photooxidation, stomatal closure limit rate. C4 plants have higher light saturation points. CO2 concentration: rate increases with [CO2] up to saturation. Current atmospheric CO2 (421 ppm) is limiting for C3 plants. Greenhouse CO2 enrichment increases C3 productivity. Temperature: C3: optimal 25-30°C. Above 35°C: photorespiration greatly increases, net photosynthesis declines. C4: optimal 35-40°C (higher temperature tolerance due to CO2 concentration mechanism). Water: stomatal closure under drought reduces CO2 entry. Direct damage to photosynthetic apparatus at severe water stress. CAM plants: extreme water efficiency (stomata open only at night). Mineral nutrients: Mg (chlorophyll component), Fe (ferredoxin, cytochromes), Mn (water splitting complex), N (proteins), P (ATP, NADPH).

5. Photorespiration and C2 Cycle

Photorespiration: occurs in all C3 plants, especially at high temperature and high O2/CO2 ratio. RuBisCO oxygenase reaction: RuBP + O2 → phosphoglycolate (2C) + 3-PGA (3C). Phosphoglycolate recycled in C2 cycle (glycolate pathway): chloroplast → peroxisome → mitochondria → back to chloroplast. Per 2 phosphoglycolate: 1 CO2 released, 1 NH3 released (refixed by GS-GOGAT), 1 3-PGA recovered. Net loss: ~25% of fixed carbon at 25°C. Increases to ~50% at 35°C. C4 plants: Kranz anatomy - ring of bundle sheath cells surrounding vascular bundle, enclosed by mesophyll cells. PEP carboxylase (no oxygenase activity) in mesophyll concentrates CO2. RuBisCO only in bundle sheath - surrounded by high CO2 = no photorespiration. CO2 pump uses 2 ATP per CO2 concentrated. Energy cost: C4 uses ~30 ATP per CO2 fixed vs ~18 ATP in C3. But gain in efficiency at high temp outweighs extra ATP cost.

6. Respiration in Plants

Glycolysis: cytoplasm. Glucose (6C) to 2 pyruvate (3C). Net: 2 ATP, 2 NADH. Aerobic respiration: Pyruvate decarboxylation: pyruvate to acetyl-CoA + CO2 + NADH. Krebs cycle: mitochondrial matrix. Per turn: 3 NADH + 1 FADH2 + 1 GTP + 2 CO2. ETC and oxidative phosphorylation: inner mitochondrial membrane. NADH and FADH2 oxidised. Proton gradient drives ATP synthesis. ~30-32 ATP per glucose total. Respiratory quotient (RQ) = CO2 released / O2 consumed. Carbohydrate: RQ = 1.0. Fat: RQ ≈ 0.7 (more H per C than carbohydrate, needs more O2). Protein: RQ ≈ 0.8. Anaerobic respiration (fermentation): no O2. Yeast: glucose → 2 ethanol + 2 CO2. Net: 2 ATP. Bacteria, mammalian muscle: glucose → 2 lactate. Net: 2 ATP. Krebs cycle also supplies carbon skeletons for biosynthesis (amino acids, nucleotides, fatty acids).

7. Mineral Nutrition

Macronutrients (required in large amounts): C, H, O (from air and water). Mineral macronutrients: N, P, K, Ca, Mg, S. Micronutrients (trace elements): Fe, Mn, Cu, Zn, Mo, B, Cl, Ni. Essential element criteria: deficiency causes abnormal growth/development. Cannot be substituted by another element. Direct role in plant metabolism. Nitrogen: most limiting nutrient in most ecosystems. Nitrate (NO3-) and ammonium (NH4+) uptake. Nitrogen fixation: biological (Rhizobium, Azotobacter, cyanobacteria), industrial (Haber-Bosch). Deficiency: yellowing (chlorosis), especially old leaves. Iron: needed for chlorophyll synthesis, ferredoxin, cytochromes. Deficiency: chlorosis of young leaves. Magnesium: central atom of chlorophyll. Deficiency: interveinal chlorosis. Phosphorus: ATP, nucleic acids, phospholipids. Deficiency: purple leaves (anthocyanin accumulation), reduced growth. Potassium: osmotic regulation, stomatal opening, enzyme activation.

8. Transport in Plants

Water uptake: osmosis from soil into root hairs. Apoplast pathway (through cell walls). Symplast pathway (through plasmodesmata and cytoplasm). Casparian strip in endodermis: forces water through symplast (controls ion entry to xylem). Transpiration pull (cohesion-tension theory): evaporation from mesophyll cells → tension in water column → water pulled up xylem (cohesion of water molecules). Xylem: dead cells (tracheids, vessel elements). Pressure flow (Munch hypothesis) for phloem transport: sugars loaded at source (leaf), increase osmotic pressure, water enters, creates turgor pressure. At sink (root, fruit), sugars unloaded, water exits, turgor reduced. Pressure gradient from source to sink drives sugar flow in phloem. Phloem: living cells (sieve tubes + companion cells). Stomatal regulation: guard cells absorb K+ and water in light → turgor increases → stomata open. ABA (abscisic acid): causes stomatal closure during water stress. Aquaporins: facilitate water transport across membranes.

Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why did C4 photosynthesis evolve independently ~30 times? ⌄
C4 photosynthesis provides such a strong selective advantage in hot, high-light, sometimes dry environments that natural selection repeatedly discovered this pathway solution independently. The advantage: suppresses photorespiration (which wastes ~25-50% of fixed carbon at high temperatures). Higher water use efficiency (higher photosynthesis per water used, since CO2 concentration allows more photosynthesis per stomatal opening). Higher nitrogen use efficiency (more photosynthesis per unit RuBisCO). Particularly advantageous when: atmospheric CO2 low (during glacial periods, CO2 fell to ~180 ppm - near C3 compensation point), temperature high, light intense. C4 grasses expanded dramatically in late Miocene (~8 MYA) when CO2 dropped and tropical climates became more seasonal. The C4 syndrome requires multiple gene changes (PEP carboxylase, carbonic anhydrase, Kranz anatomy, metabolite transporters) - yet it independently evolved ~30 times because the selection pressure was so strong.
2. Compare PEP carboxylase and RuBisCO as CO2-fixing enzymes? ⌄
PEP carboxylase (PEPC): fixes CO2 as bicarbonate (HCO3-) + PEP → OAA. Km for CO2: very low (~1-5 microM). No oxygenase activity (cannot use O2 as substrate). Speed: fast (~1000 reactions/sec). Specific for C4 and CAM plants mesophyll. RuBisCO: fixes CO2 directly + RuBP → 2 PGA. Km for CO2: higher (~8-12 microM). Has BOTH carboxylase and oxygenase activities. Speed: very slow (~3 reactions/sec). Found in all photosynthetic organisms. The contrast is striking: PEPC is much better at scavenging CO2 at low concentrations and has no wasteful oxygenase activity. C4 plants use PEPC to pre-concentrate CO2, then feed concentrated CO2 to RuBisCO - getting the best of both enzymes. RuBisCO cannot be replaced entirely because it produces 3-PGA that feeds directly into the Calvin cycle.
3. What is Kranz anatomy and why is it essential for C4 photosynthesis? ⌄
Kranz anatomy (German: "Kranz" = wreath/ring): distinctive leaf structure of C4 plants. Bundle sheath cells: thick-walled cells surrounding vascular bundles in a ring. Large chloroplasts (with starch granules), high RuBisCO. Receives concentrated CO2 from mesophyll. Calvin cycle runs here. Mesophyll cells: surrounding bundle sheath, contain PEP carboxylase. Fix atmospheric CO2 into C4 acids. Send C4 acids to bundle sheath via plasmodesmata. Without Kranz anatomy: no spatial separation of CO2 fixation and Calvin cycle. CO2 pumped to bundle sheath would leak out. The physical separation by a layer of bundle sheath cells creates a "CO2 concentrating mechanism" - like a sealed pressurised container. CO2 concentration inside bundle sheath: 10x atmospheric CO2. This is precisely the concentration at which RuBisCO oxygenase activity is fully suppressed. Kranz anatomy also requires plasmodesmatal connections between mesophyll and bundle sheath for metabolite exchange.
4. How does CAM photosynthesis differ from C4? ⌄
CAM (Crassulacean Acid Metabolism): temporal separation of CO2 fixation. Night (stomata open): PEP carboxylase fixes CO2 into malate. Stored as malic acid in vacuoles. Day (stomata closed): malate decarboxylated → CO2 released into leaf airspace. CO2 fixed by RuBisCO (Calvin cycle). C4: spatial separation (mesophyll vs bundle sheath), same time of day. CAM: temporal separation (night vs day), same cell. Advantage of CAM: extreme water efficiency (stomata open only at night when temperature lower = less evaporative water loss). Disadvantage: slow growth (nighttime CO2 fixation limited by vacuole malic acid capacity). CAM plants: cacti, Agave, pineapple, Opuntia, many succulents, some orchids and bromeliads. Comparison: C3 = cool, moist habitats. C4 = hot, sunny, often dry habitats. CAM = very dry (desert) habitats. All three use Calvin cycle ultimately but differ in when/where initial CO2 fixation occurs.
5. What is the significance of the C4 crop revolution for food security? ⌄
C4 crops (maize, sugarcane, sorghum, millet) are among the world's most productive crops: Maize: world's #1 crop by volume (~1.2 billion tonnes/year). Used for food, animal feed, biofuel. Sugarcane: world's #1 sugar source. Also major biofuel crop (Brazil: sugarcane ethanol). Sorghum: drought-tolerant staple in Africa and Asia. Finger millet, pearl millet: important in hot, dry regions of India. These crops are more productive per unit land, water, and nitrogen than C3 crops in tropical environments. Converting C3 staples (rice, wheat) to C4: major ongoing research effort (C4 Rice Project, IRRI). If successful: could increase rice yields by 50%, dramatically reducing water and fertiliser requirements. Challenges: rice is diploid annual grass (potentially suitable for C4 engineering). But requires 3+ genes + Kranz anatomy structural changes. CRISPR/gene editing approaches being tested. High-stakes global food security research.
Previous Questions
Q.
Logistic growth equation dN/dt rN K-N/K carrying capacity S-shaped sigmoid
Biology . dN/dt = rN(K-N)/K
Q.
Basic amino acids Lysine Arginine Histidine positively charged pH 7.4
Biology . Lysine and Arginine
Q.
Ectoparasite Pediculus humanus head louse on surface host body scalp
Biology . Pediculus humanus
Q.
Convergent evolution analogous organs unrelated organisms similar environment
Biology . Convergent evolution
Q.
Meselson Stahl semi-conservative replication 15N 14N Statement I correct
Biology . I correct II incorrect