HomePhysics › Q31
PhysicsElectrostatics
Consider two uncharged capacitors of equal capacitance 200 pF. One of them is charged by a 100 V supply and disconnected. Now this capacitor is connected to the uncharged capacitor. The amount of electrostatic energy lost in the process is :
Options
1
0·5 × 10⁻⁶ J
2
1·0 × 10⁻⁶ J
3
0·5 J
4
1·0 J
Correct Answer
Option 1 : 0·5 × 10⁻⁶ J
Step-by-Step Solution
1

Initial energy (only C₁ is charged, C₂ is uncharged):

Uᵢ = ½CV² = ½ × 200×10⁻¹² × (100)² = ½ × 200×10⁻¹² × 10⁴

Uᵢ = 1·0 × 10⁻⁶ J

2

Common voltage after connection (charge is conserved):

Total charge Q = CV = 200×10⁻¹² × 100 = 2×10⁻⁸ C

Total capacitance = C + C = 2C = 400 pF

V' = Q/(2C) = CV/(2C) = V/2 = 50 V

3

Final energy (both capacitors at 50 V):

Uf = ½(2C)V'² = ½ × 400×10⁻¹² × (50)²

Uf = ½ × 400×10⁻¹² × 2500 = 0·5 × 10⁻⁶ J

4

Energy lost:

ΔU = Uᵢ − Uf = 1·0×10⁻⁶ − 0·5×10⁻⁶ = 0·5 × 10⁻⁶ J

ΔU = ½CV² − ½(2C)(V/2)² = ½CV² − ¼CV² = ¼CV²

= ¼ × 200×10⁻¹² × 10⁴ = 0·5 × 10⁻⁶ J

Energy lost = HALF the initial energy (always, for identical capacitors)

Theory: Capacitors — Charging, Energy & Combinations
1. Energy Stored in a Capacitor

A capacitor stores electrical energy in the electric field between its plates. The energy stored is: U = ½CV² = Q²/(2C) = QV/2. All three forms are equivalent (using Q = CV). For this problem: U = ½ × 200×10⁻¹² × (100)² = 10⁻⁶ J = 1 μJ. This energy comes from the work done by the battery in moving charge from one plate to the other, against the growing electric field.

2. Why is Energy Lost When Capacitors Share Charge?

When a charged capacitor (V) is connected to an uncharged identical capacitor, charge flows until both reach the same potential V/2. Charge is conserved: Q_initial = Q_final. But energy is NOT conserved — half is lost. Where does it go? To heat in the connecting wires (even if resistance is zero, there is still a spark — electromagnetic radiation is emitted). This is an unavoidable consequence of the discontinuous redistribution of charge. It's a fundamental result: connecting two identical capacitors always wastes exactly 50% of the initial energy, regardless of the capacitance value.

3. Charge Conservation vs Energy Conservation

📌 Charge is always conserved when capacitors are connected

📌 Total charge before = Total charge after: Q = CV (on C₁) + 0 (on C₂) = CV

📌 After connection: Q₁' + Q₂' = Q₁ + Q₂ → still = CV

📌 Energy is NOT conserved — half is lost to heat/radiation

📌 Final energy = ½ × initial energy (for identical capacitors)

📌 The "missing" energy appears as heat in wires or EM radiation

4. Capacitors in Series and Parallel

Series combination: 1/C_eq = 1/C₁ + 1/C₂ + 1/C₃ + .... Same charge Q on each capacitor; voltages add: V = V₁ + V₂ + .... Used when need higher voltage rating. Parallel combination: C_eq = C₁ + C₂ + C₃ + .... Same voltage V across each; charges add: Q = Q₁ + Q₂ + .... Used when need higher capacitance. In this problem: when the two capacitors are connected (positive plate to positive, negative to negative), they are effectively in parallel: C_eq = C₁ + C₂ = 2C.

5. Dielectric in Capacitors

Inserting a dielectric (insulating material) between capacitor plates increases capacitance: C = κC₀ = κε₀A/d, where κ is the dielectric constant (κ ≥ 1). This happens because the dielectric gets polarised — induced surface charges partially cancel the plate charges, reducing the effective electric field, allowing more charge to be stored at the same voltage. Effect on a charged capacitor: (1) Connected to battery: charge increases (Q = κCV), energy increases, electric field stays same. (2) Disconnected from battery: voltage decreases, energy decreases (energy used to pull in the dielectric).

6. Parallel Plate Capacitor

📌 Capacitance: C = ε₀A/d (in vacuum), C = κε₀A/d (with dielectric)

📌 Electric field between plates: E = σ/ε₀ = V/d (uniform)

📌 Energy density in electric field: u = ½ε₀E² J/m³

📌 Total energy: U = u × Volume = ½ε₀E² × Ad = ½CV²

📌 Force between plates: F = Q²/(2ε₀A) = ½ε₀E²A (attractive)

📌 Capacitance increases if: A increases, d decreases, κ increases

7. Capacitors in Real Life

Capacitors are used everywhere in electronics. Electrolytic capacitors (large C, 1μF–10,000μF): used for power supply filtering, audio coupling. Ceramic capacitors (small C, 1pF–1μF): used in high-frequency circuits. Variable capacitors: used in radio tuning. Supercapacitors (up to farads!): energy storage in hybrid vehicles, backup power. Camera flash: capacitor stores charge, then dumps it quickly through the flash bulb — much higher instantaneous power than battery alone can provide.

8. Capacitor as Energy Storage vs Battery

Both capacitors and batteries store energy, but very differently. Capacitors: store energy in electric fields, charge/discharge extremely fast (microseconds to milliseconds), lower energy density (Wh/kg) but higher power density (W/kg). Batteries: store energy in chemical bonds, slow to charge (hours), higher energy density but lower power density. Supercapacitors fill the gap. A 200 pF capacitor at 100V stores only 1 μJ — a typical AA battery stores ~3000 Wh × 10⁻⁶ = 3 Wh = 10,800 J — about 10 billion times more energy!

Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why is exactly half the energy lost?
For two identical capacitors (C each): Initial energy Uᵢ = ½CV². After sharing: V' = V/2, final energy Uf = ½(2C)(V/2)² = ½(2C)(V²/4) = CV²/4 = Uᵢ/2. So exactly half is always lost when two IDENTICAL uncharged capacitors share charge. For non-identical capacitors: ΔU = C₁C₂(V₁−V₂)²/[2(C₁+C₂)] — energy lost depends on the voltage difference.
2. Is charge conserved in this process?
Yes. Initial charge: Q = CV = 200×10⁻¹² × 100 = 2×10⁻⁸ C (on C₁), zero on C₂. Final charge: each capacitor has charge Q' = C×V' = 200×10⁻¹² × 50 = 10⁻⁸ C. Total final charge = 2×10⁻⁸ C = initial charge. ✓ Charge is always conserved — it just redistributes between the two capacitors.
3. What if the capacitors are different (C₁ ≠ C₂)?
Common voltage: V' = C₁V₁/(C₁+C₂) (when C₂ is uncharged). Energy lost: ΔU = C₁C₂V₁²/[2(C₁+C₂)]. The fraction of energy lost = C₂/(C₁+C₂). For identical capacitors (C₁=C₂=C): fraction = C/(2C) = ½ → always 50%. For C₂ >> C₁: fraction → 1 (almost all energy lost). For C₂ << C₁: fraction → 0 (very little energy lost — voltage barely changes).
4. What is the common voltage formula?
When capacitor C₁ (charged to V₁) is connected to C₂ (charged to V₂), the common voltage is: V' = (C₁V₁ + C₂V₂)/(C₁ + C₂). This comes from charge conservation: Q₁ + Q₂ = Q₁' + Q₂', so C₁V₁ + C₂V₂ = (C₁+C₂)V'. For this problem: V' = (CV + C×0)/(C+C) = CV/(2C) = V/2 = 50 V.
5. Where does the lost energy go?
The energy goes into: (1) Heating the connecting wires — even zero-resistance wires have some inductance, causing oscillating currents that eventually damp to heat. (2) Electromagnetic radiation (radio waves) emitted when current suddenly starts flowing. Even in the ideal case (zero resistance, zero inductance), quantum mechanics shows that energy must be radiated. This is fundamentally unavoidable — you cannot connect two capacitors at different potentials without losing energy.
6. How is energy stored in a capacitor related to electric field?
Energy density u = ½ε₀E² J/m³. Total energy U = u × (volume between plates) = ½ε₀E² × Ad. For parallel plate capacitor: E = V/d, so U = ½ε₀(V/d)²×Ad = ½ε₀V²A/d = ½CV². Both formulas give the same result, but the field-based formula shows energy is stored distributed throughout the electric field, not just on the plates.
7. What happens if we connect positive plate to negative plate?
If positive plate of C₁ is connected to negative plate of C₂ (opposite polarity connection): charges cancel. Q_net = CV − CV = 0 (for identical capacitors). Both capacitors end up with zero charge, zero voltage. All stored energy (1 μJ) is lost to heat — 100% energy loss! This is worse than same-polarity connection (50% loss). The general formula: ΔU = C₁C₂(V₁−V₂)²/[2(C₁+C₂)]. Opposite polarity: V₂ = −V → ΔU = C₁C₂(2V)²/[2(2C)] = CV².
8. What is the energy stored in the electric field of a spherical capacitor?
An isolated sphere of radius R acts as a capacitor (with the other plate at infinity): C = 4πε₀R. Potential V = Q/(4πε₀R). Energy U = Q²/(8πε₀R) = ½CV². For Earth (R = 6.4×10⁶ m): C = 4π×8.85×10⁻¹²×6.4×10⁶ ≈ 710 μF. A large capacitor — but compared to the Earth's natural electric field, its stored energy is enormous. Lightning is a discharge of this natural capacitor.
Previous Questions
Q.
Metallic cube mass 5·580 kg, side 9·0 cm — density with sig figs
Units & Measurements · Answer: 7·7 × 10³ kg/m³
Q.
Concave lens ray parallel to principal axis — after refraction
Ray Optics · Answer: Appears to diverge from first principal focus
Q.
AC circuit 1kΩ, 0·1μF, 1mH series — resonance frequency
Alternating Current · Answer: 15·9 kHz
Q.
Speed of light taken as unity — Sun-Earth distance in new unit
Units & Measurements · Answer: 400
Q.
Match — Young's Modulus, Compressibility, Bulk Modulus, Poisson's Ratio
Properties of Matter · Answer: A-II, B-III, C-IV, D-I