Home › Biology › Q
BiologyEvolution

Assertion (A): Natural selection is the mechanism of evolution proposed by Charles Darwin.
Reason (R): Natural selection acts on the heritable variation present in population, and individuals with favourable variations survive and reproduce more successfully.
Choose the correct option:

R
Solution written and verified by Roshan, science educator with 5 years of experience teaching NEET and JEE aspirants. Last reviewed September 2026.
Options
1
Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
2
Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A
3
A is true but R is false
4
A is false but R is true
Correct Answer
Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
Solution
1

Assertion A: Darwin proposed natural selection as mechanism of evolution. TRUE ✓

Published in "On the Origin of Species" (1859). Natural selection = individuals with favourable heritable traits reproduce more.

2

Reason R: Natural selection acts on heritable variation; favourable variants survive and reproduce more. TRUE ✓

R correctly explains the mechanism by which A works. Answer: Both true, R explains A

Both A and R true. R is the correct explanation of A.
Darwin: natural selection on heritable variation → differential reproduction → evolution
Theory: Evolution
1. Darwin's Theory of Natural Selection

Charles Darwin (1809-1882): published "On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection" (1859). Alfred Russel Wallace co-developed the theory independently (1858). Darwin's observations during Beagle voyage (1831-1836): especially Galapagos finches (14 species from one ancestor, different beak shapes for different food sources). Darwin's arguments for natural selection: (1) Overproduction: all species produce more offspring than can survive. (2) Struggle for existence: competition for limited resources. (3) Variation: individuals within a population vary in heritable traits. (4) Survival of the fittest: individuals with favourable variations survive more often (differential survival). (5) Inheritance of favourable traits: survivors pass on their advantages. (6) Gradual accumulation of differences → new species. What Darwin did NOT know: mechanism of inheritance (genes), source of new variation (mutations), molecular basis. Neo-Darwinism/Modern Synthesis (1930s-1950s) integrated Darwin's theory with Mendelian genetics and population genetics.

2. Evidences for Evolution

Fossil evidence: preserved remains/impressions of past organisms. Geological strata → relative dating. Carbon-14 (up to 50,000 yr), uranium-lead (millions of years) → absolute dating. Transitional fossils: Archaeopteryx (reptile-bird), Tiktaalik (fish-tetrapod), Pakicetus (land mammal-whale). Comparative anatomy: Homologous organs: same structure, different function. Forelimb of human, whale, bat, horse (all have same bones: humerus, radius, ulna, carpals, phalanges) → common ancestry. Analogous organs: different structure, same function. Wings of bird and butterfly → convergent evolution. Vestigial organs: reduced, non-functional structures from ancestors. Human: appendix, ear muscles, coccyx, wisdom teeth. Whale: pelvic bones. Embryological evidence: embryos of vertebrates are very similar in early stages → shared ancestry. Gill slits and tails in human embryos (Haeckel's recapitulation theory — "ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny" is an oversimplification but embryological similarities are real evidence).

3. Types of Natural Selection

Directional selection: shifts the population mean in one direction. Example: peppered moth (Biston betularia) — industrial melanism. Before industrialisation: light-coloured moths survived on lichen-covered trees. After: soot covered trees → dark moths survived → dark allele increased. Reverse after pollution reduction. Stabilising selection: favours intermediate phenotypes, reduces variation. Example: human birth weight (too small or too large → higher mortality; intermediate weight most survive). Most common type in stable environments. Disruptive (diversifying) selection: favours both extremes, eliminates intermediate. Rare. Example: Coho salmon (two male morphs: large aggressive vs small "sneaker" males). Can lead to sympatric speciation. Sexual selection: mates choose based on certain traits → evolution of secondary sex characters. Example: peacock tail (reduces survival but increases mating success), stag antlers, bird of paradise plumage. Can oppose natural selection.

4. Modern Synthetic Theory (Neo-Darwinism)

Modern Synthesis integrated: Darwin's natural selection + Mendelian genetics + population genetics (Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium) + mutation theory (de Vries) + geographical isolation (speciation). Main components: (1) Mutation: ultimate source of new alleles. (2) Recombination: reshuffles existing alleles → new genotype combinations. (3) Natural selection: changes allele frequencies. (4) Genetic drift: random changes in allele frequencies (important in small populations). (5) Gene flow: movement of alleles between populations (reduces differentiation). (6) Isolation: geographic, reproductive → prevents gene flow → speciation. Hardy-Weinberg law: in a large random-mating population without selection, mutation, migration, or drift: allele frequencies remain constant (equilibrium). Deviations from HW = evolution is occurring.

5. Speciation

Speciation: formation of new species from existing species. Allopatric speciation (geographic isolation): populations physically separated (mountain, ocean, desert) → different selective pressures → accumulate differences → reproductive isolation develops. Example: Darwin's finches, Hawaiian honeycreepers. Sympatric speciation: new species form without geographic isolation. Rarer in animals, more common in plants. Mechanisms: polyploidy (especially in plants, e.g., wheat = hexaploid), habitat differentiation, assortative mating. Species concept: Biological species concept (Mayr): group of organisms that can interbreed and produce fertile offspring. Limitations: doesn't apply to asexual organisms, allopatric populations, fossils. Other concepts: morphological, phylogenetic, ecological. Hybrid zones: areas where two partially reproductively isolated species meet and occasionally hybridise. Can be stabile or expand/collapse.

6. Mechanisms of Evolutionary Change

Mutation: changes in DNA sequence. Point mutations (substitution, insertion, deletion). Chromosomal mutations (inversion, translocation, deletion, duplication). Most mutations are neutral or slightly deleterious. Positive mutations rare but crucial. Mutation rate: ~10⁻⁸ to 10⁻⁶ per nucleotide per replication. Recombination: crossing over during meiosis → new allele combinations. Sexual reproduction greatly amplifies variation available for selection. Genetic drift: random changes in allele frequency. Important in small populations. Founder effect: small group establishes new population → limited genetic diversity. Example: Old Order Amish (Ellis-van Creveld syndrome). Bottleneck effect: population reduced drastically → loss of alleles. Example: cheetahs (extremely low genetic diversity). Gene flow/Migration: movement of individuals/gametes between populations → homogenises allele frequencies → reduces population differentiation.

7. Hardy-Weinberg Equilibrium

H-W Law: in ideal population (large, random mating, no mutation, no selection, no migration): allele frequencies remain constant. If allele A has frequency $p$ and allele a has frequency $q$ ($p + q = 1$): genotype frequencies = $p^2$ (AA) + $2pq$ (Aa) + $q^2$ (aa) = 1. Uses: (1) Baseline to measure evolution (deviations from HW = evolution). (2) Calculate allele frequencies from phenotype data. Example: if 1% of population shows recessive phenotype ($q^2 = 0.01$): $q = 0.1$, $p = 0.9$, carrier frequency $= 2pq = 2(0.9)(0.1) = 18\%$. Agents of evolutionary change (disturb H-W): mutation, natural selection, genetic drift, gene flow (migration), non-random mating. NEET application: calculate carrier frequency for autosomal recessive conditions.

8. Human Evolution

Primates: order including prosimians, monkeys, apes, humans. Evolved from insectivore-like ancestors ~80 million years ago (MYA). Key evolutionary events: 55 MYA: first primates. 35 MYA: Old World monkeys separate. 25 MYA: gibbons separate. 15 MYA: orangutans. 10 MYA: gorillas. 7 MYA: chimpanzee and human lineages diverge. ~7% DNA difference between human and chimp (98%+ similar). Hominid evolution: Australopithecus (~4 MYA, Africa, bipedal, small brain ~400 cc). Homo habilis (2.5-1.5 MYA, first tool use, brain ~650 cc). Homo erectus (1.8-0.3 MYA, spread out of Africa, fire, brain ~900-1100 cc). Homo heidelbergensis (0.7-0.2 MYA). Homo neanderthalensis (400-40,000 years ago, Europe/Middle East, brain ~1450 cc, ritual burial). Homo sapiens (anatomically modern: 300,000 years ago; behaviourally modern: 50,000 years ago). Out of Africa hypothesis: modern humans evolved in Africa then spread worldwide and replaced archaic humans.

Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why is natural selection considered a "blind" process? ⌄
Natural selection is "blind" because it has no foresight or purpose — it simply favours traits that increase reproductive success in the CURRENT environment. It cannot plan for future changes. Example: antibiotic resistance in bacteria develops because rare resistant mutants survive antibiotic treatment — not because the bacteria "know" they need to become resistant. The resistance mutation existed randomly before antibiotic exposure; selection simply increased its frequency. Similarly, the Galapagos finches did not "decide" to develop different beak shapes — birds with beak shapes suited to available food sources survived better in their specific island environment. Natural selection is also "local" — it optimises for current conditions, not absolute perfection. This is why vestigial organs exist (appendix, ear muscles) — they were useful in ancestors and are not yet eliminated because they are not sufficiently harmful to select against.
2. What is the difference between Darwinism and Lamarckism? ⌄
Lamarck (1809, "Philosophie Zoologique"): proposed inheritance of acquired characteristics. Two laws: (1) Use and disuse: organs used more develop; unused organs degenerate. (2) Inheritance of acquired characters: traits acquired during lifetime are passed to offspring. Example: giraffes stretched necks reaching higher leaves → offspring inherited longer necks. Darwinism: variation exists naturally in population. Natural selection acts on this pre-existing variation — does not create it. Acquired characters (muscle development from exercise, tanned skin, etc.) are NOT inherited because somatic changes do not affect germline DNA (Weismann barrier). Molecular support for Darwin: Lamarckian inheritance is impossible under normal circumstances (changes to somatic cell DNA are not transmitted via gametes). Neo-Lamarckism/Epigenetics: some epigenetic changes CAN be transgenerationally inherited — this is an active research area but does not support Lamarck's mechanism.
3. What is "fitness" in the context of natural selection? ⌄
Evolutionary fitness is NOT the same as physical fitness or strength. Fitness = reproductive success = number of offspring an individual produces that survive to reproduce. An organism with high fitness contributes more genes to the next generation. A fragile orchid that produces 10,000 seeds may be "fitter" than a powerful tiger that has 2 cubs. Relative fitness: compared to other genotypes in the same population. Absolute fitness = number of offspring; relative fitness = scaled to most successful genotype. Examples: Peacock tail: male with most elaborate tail has highest mating success → highest fitness despite tail reducing survival (predation risk). Sickle cell trait: heterozygotes (HbA/HbS) have higher fitness in malaria-endemic regions than either homozygote (HbA/HbA susceptible to malaria; HbS/HbS dies of sickle cell disease). This is balancing selection (heterozygote advantage/overdominance).
4. Explain industrial melanism as evidence for natural selection? ⌄
Peppered moth (Biston betularia) study (Kettlewell): Two forms: light-coloured (typica) and dark/melanic (carbonaria). Before industrialisation (pre-1850s): lichen-covered trees → light moths camouflaged → survived better. Dark moths were rare (visible to predators). After industrialisation: soot covered tree bark → dark moths camouflaged → light moths visible and eaten more. By 1900: dark moths were 98% of population in polluted areas. After Clean Air Acts (1950s-1970s): lichen returned → light moths increased again in cleaned areas. This is directional selection: changed environment → changed selection pressure → changed allele frequency. Criticised: Kettlewell's photos were staged (moths placed unnaturally) but the core observation (frequency changes) is valid and replicated.
5. What is sexual selection and how does it differ from natural selection? ⌄
Both are forms of selection (differential reproduction based on heritable traits). Natural selection: traits increase survival AND reproduction relative to environment. Sexual selection: traits increase reproductive SUCCESS specifically through mate choice or competition, even if they reduce survival. Two types: Intrasexual selection (male-male competition): antlers in deer, horns in beetles. Traits that help males compete for females. Intersexual selection (female choice): peacock tail, bird of paradise plumage, red-winged blackbird epaulettes. Males evolve elaborate ornaments because females prefer them. Runaway selection (Fisher's runaway): once females have a preference, males with preferred trait AND sons of those males succeed → positive feedback → trait exaggerates beyond practical utility (e.g., peacock tail becomes absurdly large). Handicap principle (Zahavi): elaborate ornaments are "honest signals" — only genuinely fit males can afford the cost of maintaining them.
Previous Questions
Q.
Ecosystem productivity unit KCal m-2 yr-1 GPP NPP measurement
Biology · Answer: (KCal m⁻²) yr⁻¹
Q.
Colloids types sol gel foam aerosol paint cheese whipped cream fog
Chemistry · Answer: A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
Q.
Xenon hybridisation XeO3 sp3 XeF2 sp3d XeOF4 sp3d2 XeF6 sp3d3
Chemistry · Answer: A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
Q.
N2 O2 2NO endothermic high temperature A C E only equilibrium
Chemistry · Answer: A, C and E only
Q.
Dalton atomic theory law of gaseous volumes Gay-Lussac Avogadro
Chemistry · Answer: Law of gaseous volumes